Author Archives: vhoagland

Thessalonians and the Gospel of Matthew

We will be reading from St.Paul’s 1st Letter to the Thessalonians this week and ending our reading from the Gospel of Matthew. Next Monday, the 22nd Week of Ordinary Time we begin the Gospel of Luke.

! Thessalonians was written early on, during Paul’s 2nd missionary journey with Silvanus and Timothy. Written about 20 years after the death and resurrection of Jesus, the letter is Paul’s first  letter and the first writing of  the New Testament.  

Paul’s message to the people of Thessalonika can be summarized in a sentence.  “ For if we believe that Jesus died and rose, so too will God, through Jesus, bring with him those who have fallen asleep” (Thes. 4:14)

In his letter Paul commends the Thessalonians, who are mostly Gentiles. They received Paul’s message through the power of the Holy Spirit,  not just through Paul’s words.  Paul’s converts are experiencing strong opposition from Jews as well as from their own people, who seem to portray Paul and his companions as religious peddlers trying to profit from a gullible audience.

Paul mentions  the persecution going on in Judea. In this week’s gospel readings  from Matthew Jesus denounces in strong terms the scribes and Pharisees who oppose him.   Commentators believe Matthew’s gospel may well describe the opposition Jesus’ followers faced after his death and resurrection, as well as what he faced in his lifetime. Perhaps this is why the compilers of our lectionary put these two readings together?

Paul assumes the final coming of Jesus will occur in his own lifetime, but the day is unknown. It will come as a “thief in the night.” ( 1 Thes 5: 1-2) Instead of focusing on the last days, Paul tells the Thessalonians to live today. The same theme is repeated in Matthew’s gospel this week. (Thursday)“Stay awake! For you do not know on which day your Lord will come.” It will come like a thief.

(Matt 42:22-41)

2nd Thessalonians, Matthew, Monica and Augustine. Again?

Year by year our liturgy takes us through readings from the Old and New Testaments, the same feasts and celebrations of saints, the same prayers. Why the repetition?

The liturgy calls for deep reading. Deep reading is different than the quick reading we do looking up facts.

Facts only take us so far. “What time is it?”and “What’s the meaning of time?” are different questions. One can be answered right away, the other calls for a journey of reflection. If we hear ourselves say “I know this already” as we approach the 1st Letter to the Thessalonians and the Gospel of Mathew——our readings this week—-we close a door to wisdom. 

The liturgy is a daily bread. We learn little by little at its table. We’re slow learners. We forget. So we need to read the same scriptures and say the same prayers and celebrate our familiar saints. “If today you hear his voice, harden not your hearts.” We are called to deep reading.

We hear God’s voice in our lectionary readings this week and till next Tuesday from Paul’s Letter to the Thessalonians. It’s the earliest writing of the New Testament, taking us back to the church at its beginnings. Thessalonians provides four readings for morning and evening prayer so this is a good time to deepen our understanding of this book of scripture.

What have we to learn from those chapters of Matthew we read from this week? What can Monica and Augustine, saints we celebrate this week, have to say? “From their place in heaven they guide us still.”

Ai will probably be recreating 1st century Thessaloniki soon, but in the meantime I found this recent YouTube presentation, an interesting introduction to the world St. Paul and his companions entered on their journey to this city in Macedonia. Like other cities Paul visited, it was on the main road to Rome.

Bartholomew, the Apostle: August 24

IMG (160)
Cana today

August 24th is the feast of the apostle Bartholomew, also identified as Nathaniel,  from Cana in Galilee, only a few miles from Nazareth.  Like Nazareth, Cana attracted little interest in Jesus’ time, yet it played  a major role in Jesus’ early life and  mission.

In John’s gospel,  Jesus turns water into wine at a wedding in Cana, his first “sign” that God’s kingdom would come. (Jn 2, 1-12) The family faced a wedding nightmare: the wine was running out and embarrassment was sure to come.

Catholic Church, Cana
Catholic Church, Cana
cana carol rothstein 7

Was the family related to Jesus? Or Bartholomew?  At least they were close. Why else would Jesus, his mother and his disciples be at the celebration?

The miracle was special,. More than saving a family from embarrassment, it’s a sign in John’s gospel of God’s great love for ordinary people in ordinary towns everywhere. God delights in them, says the Prophet Isaiah, whose words often accompany the Cana miracle,  Cana signifies poor Israel, whom God loves with all the ardor of a “young man marrying a virgin,” God’s love, bountiful, restoring, overflowing with delight, goes out to this poor place, as well as poor places everywhere.

Jesus performed another miracle at Cana, John’s gospel says, another sign of the coming kingdom. Besides the miracle at the wedding, Jesus cured the dying son of a government official from Capernaum, whose ” father came to Cana because he heard that Jesus was there. (John 4.46-54) Jesus saved his son from death.

cana carol rothstein

Through the centuries Cana hasn’t prospered much. It’s not much to look at today.  In the late 19th century, a visiting English vicar described it this way:

“ (Kefr Kenna) lies on high ground, but not on a hill…A broad prickly pear led to the group of houses which perhaps represents the New Testament Cana. Loose stones were scattered around the slope. There may be, possibly, 150 inhabitants, but one cannot envy them their huts of mud and stone, with dunghills at every corner. Huge mud ovens, like great beehives, stood at the sides of some of the houses.

“ In one house a worthy Moslem was squatting on the ground with a number of children, all with slates on which verses of the Koran had been written, which they repeated together. It was the village school, perhaps like that at Nazareth eighteen hundred years ago.

“ A small Franciscan church of white stone with a nice railed wall, with a beautiful garden at the side, had over its doorway these startling words in Latin: ‘Here Jesus Christ from water made wine.’ Some large water jars are shown inside as actually those used in the miracle, but such mock relics, however believed in by simple monks, do the faith of other people more harm than good.”

Cana’s still a poor town. Like other poor places in the world it’s waiting to be raised up to share in the splendor of the heavenly Jerusalem. God loves poor places like this, the Cana miracle says. Bartholomew came from here.

cana carol rothstein 11
Church of St. Bartholomew, Cana

St. Rose of Lima. August 23

Nicolas Correa, Museo nacional de Arte, Mexico

St Rose of Lima is the first saint of the Americas to be canonized. She’s the patroness of Peru, the Philippines and the West Indies. Her feast is August 23.

By all accounts Rose was extraordinarily beautiful from her birth. Her family, seeing how attractive she was, gave her the name, Rose. They probably envisioned a good marriage for her, improving their own fortunes, for her family struggled to make ends meet. 

But Rose, influenced by the example of St. Catherine of Siena, wanted to enter give her life to God and devote herself to a life of prayer. Her family forbade it and in spite of their opposition Rose began a life of prayer and penance at home. She was a religious rebel.

Her penances seem excessive to us today. For one thing, she minimized and disfigured her physical beauty instead of enhancing it. Instead of fine clothes she wore the simple habit of a Dominican tertiary. She shunned Lima’s social life, which prized beautiful women, for a life of prayer and fasting. Instead of cultivating influential friends, she took care of the poor and the sick. She gave herself to the poor.

When she died at 31, thousands came to her funeral at Lima’s cathedral and miracles were reported by those who prayed for her intercession.

Facing great opposition, St. Rose of Lima followed a call from God.  She resisted an arranged marriage by her family, probably supported by Dominican theologians who, following the decrees of the Council of Trent, told her she had the right to choose marriage on not. 

She herself learned something more: troubles bring suffering, but they also bring an increase in God’s grace. Here’s the saint speaking for herself:

“Our Lord and Savior lifted up his voice and said with incomparable majesty: “Let all know that grace comes after tribulation. Let them know that without the burden of afflictions it is impossible to reach the height of grace. Let them know that the gifts of grace increase as the struggles increase. Let them take care not to stray and be deceived. This is the only true stairway to paradise, and without the cross they can find no road to climb to heaven.”

When I heard these words, a strong force came upon me and seemed to place me in the middle of a street, so that I might say in a loud voice to people of every age, sex and status: “Hear, O people; hear, O nations. I am warning you about the commandment of Christ by using words that came from his own lips: We cannot obtain grace unless we suffer afflictions.

“We must heap trouble upon trouble to attain a deep participation in the divine nature, the glory of the children of God and perfect happiness of soul.”

That same force strongly urged me to proclaim the beauty of divine grace. It pressed me so that my breath came slow and forced me to sweat and pant. I felt as if my soul could no longer be kept in the prison of the body, but had burst its chains and was free and alone and going swiftly through the whole world saying: 

“If only we would learn how great it is to possess divine grace, how beautiful, how noble, how precious. How many riches it hides within itself, how many joys and delights! Without doubt they would devote all their care and concern to winning for themselves pains and afflictions. No one would complain about his cross or the troubles that come.” (Office of Readings, St. Rose of Lima)

St. Rose of Lima is honored in the Chapel of the Peruvian Saints in the Cathedral in Lima, Perus, along with St. Martin de Porres, St. Francisco Solano, and St. John Macias.

21st Sunday a: You are Peter

Jesus spent most of his ministry in the Jewish towns near the Sea of Galilee, but in today’s gospel he and his disciples travel about 25 miles north to Caesarea Phillipi at the foot of Mount Hermon. It was gentile territory, a center of Roman power, with shrines to Roman and Greek gods.

As he often does, Jesus uses what’s at hand to teach, and so here in a center of Roman power he asks his disciples, “Who do people say the Son of Man is?”

They reply, “Some say John the Baptist, others Elijah,still others Jeremiah or one of the prophets.” He said to them, “But who do you say that I am?” Simon Peter said in reply,
“You are the Christ, the Son of the living God.” Jesus said to him in reply,
“Blessed are you, Simon son of Jonah. For flesh and blood has not revealed this to you, but my heavenly Father. And so I say to you, you are Peter, and upon this rock I will build my church, and the gates of the netherworld shall not prevail against it.”

This is one of those gospels people have argued about over the centuries. “You are Peter and upon this rock I will build my church.” What mission  does Jesus give Peter? 

Some say Peter represents all of Jesus’ followers who are  “living stones” “rocks” on which his church is built. Every believer’s a rock. Some say Peter is the disciple Jesus chose, along with Paul, to bring about the birth of his church during a time of its separation from Judaism. So it was  only a temporary mission. 

Catholics see this gospel promising something more enduring. Jesus will provide guidance for his church through the centuries through the successors of Peter, the popes, the bishops of Rome.

That promise of Jesus still stands. God sends leaders, shepherds, guides, to teach and lead his people on our journey. We have the witness of popes through the centuries.

Yet, our first reading from the Prophet Isaiah invites us to see that promise is more than a promise  to Peter and the popes. 

Whether in the world or in the church, we will have the leaders we need to bring about God’s kingdom. We will never be without leaders God promises them.

That’s important to remember today, when there is so much cynicism about leadership of every kind, whether it’s the leadership of popes or priests, or parents, or teachers, or politicians. Can anyone lead us into the future? So many today give up on stakeholders in the future. So many give up on becoming parents, or teachers or even politicians– people who look to the future. So many give up on our world.

The promise Jesus makes to Peter applies to all people trying to better our world. In fact, it applies to us all, for we all have a gift for making the world better. God will give us the wisdom and strength to keep our world on its journey to become God’s kingdom. 

Today, we pray for Pope Leo,  that he continue to be a rock leading our church.

Some criticize him today for taking too much on. He’s traveling too much, they say, he’s getting into issues he doesn’t know much about, like artificial intelligence, immigration, capitalism, climate change. He should stay in his own lane.  Let him stay home and take care of the church.

Look again at our gospel today, where Jesus makes the promise of leadership to Peter, in Caesaria Philippi, a Roman stronghold. Not a safe place to begin a church, a new venture. But that’s the world Peter is called to be a rock. That’s the same kind of world Leo is called to be rock.

He will not have to stand alone, or build alone. Jesus promises to his Bread of Life. Jesus calls us too to live in the world that’s ours, however frightening it can be, and build his church. We won’t stand alone either. He is also our Bread.

The Queenship of Mary

800px-Fra_Angelico_038

“Christians live from feast to feast,” St. Athanasius said. The church’s feasts are linked to each other through the year, and every feast is linked to the great feast of the Resurrection of Jesus.

The feasts of Mary follow the pattern of the feasts of her Son, for she shares in his saving work. Following the feasts year by year, we learn the mysteries of God, little by little. Mary was blessed from her conception. ( Immaculate Conception, Dec. 8). We celebrate her birth 9 month later. (The Nativity of Mary, September 7). Her death and assumption into heaven are celebrated Augustus 15th.

The Feast of the Queenship of Mary, August 22, is part of the mystery of her assumption into heaven. Introduced into the liturgy of the Roman Catholic church in 1955, the feast celebrates the privileged place of Mary in heaven. She “was taken up body and soul into heavenly glory when her earthly life was over, and exalted by the Lord as Queen over all things.” (Second Vatican Council, Lumen Gentium 59)

Royal titles were commonly given to God and those anointed by God in the Old Testament; Christianity continued the pratice, giving royal titles to Jesus and Mary. She is called queen in traditional Christian prayers like the Hail Holy Queen (Salve regina) and Queen of Heaven (Regina Coeli):

“Hail, Holy Queen, Mother of mercy, our life, our sweetness and our hope. To you do we cry, poor banished children of Eve. To you do we send up our sighs, mourning and weeping in the valley of tears. Turn then, most gracious advocate, your eyes of mercy towards us, and after this our exile, show to us the blessed fruit of your womb, Jesus. O clement, O loving, O sweet Virgin Mary.

Pray for us, O holy Mother of God, that we may be made worthy of the promises of Christ.

Mary is a queen, but also a mother. She is the Mother of God, Mother of Jesus Christ, Mother of us all, the New Eve, given to us by her Son from the Cross through his disciple John.

Mary knows her greatness is from her Lord, as she acknowledges in her Magnificat:

“My soul proclaims the greatness of the Lord; my spirit rejoices in God, my Savior. He who is mighty has done great things to me; holy is his name.” ( Luke 1:46-55)

In the portrayal above, Fra Angelico captures Mary’s humility; she bows before her Son, her hands closed in prayer. The saints below her know that honors given to her are a reflection of the graces promised to humanity.

“Pray for us, O Holy Mother of God, that we may be made worthy of the promises of Christ.”

Friday Thoughts

Saints speak in different ways. Listen first to the prose of St. Thomas Aquinas and then the poetry of St.Bernard:

“Why did the Son of God have to suffer for us? There was a great need, and it can be considered in a twofold way: in the first place, as a remedy for sin, and secondly, as an example of how to act.

It is a remedy, for, in the face of all the evils which we incur on account of our sins, we have found relief through the passion of Christ. Yet, it is no less an example, for the passion of Christ completely suffices to fashion our lives.”  ( Thomas Aquinas)

“Where can the weak find a place of firm security and peace, except in the wounds of the Saviour? Indeed, the more secure is my place there, the more he can do to help me. The world rages, the flesh is heavy, and the devil lays his snares, but I do not fall, for my feet are planted on firm rock. I may have sinned gravely. My conscience would be distressed, but it would not be in turmoil, for I would recall the wounds of the Lord: he was wounded for our iniquities…

They pierced his hands and feet and opened his side with a spear… But the piercing nail has become a key to unlock the door, that I may see the good will of the Lord. And what can I see as I look through the hole? Both the nail and the wound cry out that God was in Christ reconciling the world to himself. The sword pierced his soul and came close to his heart, so that he might be able to feel compassion for me in my weaknesses.

Through these sacred wounds we can see the secret of his heart, the great mystery of love, the sincerity of his mercy with which he visited us from on high. Where have your love, your mercy, your compassion shone out more luminously than in your wounds, sweet, gentle Lord of mercy? More mercy than this no one has than that he lay down his life for those who are doomed to death.”  (St. Bernard)

Thomas and Bernard speak the same truth.

St. Pius X, AUGUST 21

August 21st is the Feast of St. Pius X.

Eamon Duffy in his fine study of the popes, “Saints and Sinners: A History of the Popes”, describes St. Pius X as a pope who looked forward and looked backward. His pastoral reforms of the liturgy, his encouragement of frequent Communion and reform of church prayers, for example, anticipated many of the liturgical reforms of the Second Vatican Council. In fact, he promoted the beginnings of the modern liturgical movement.

His fear for the integrity of church doctrine, on the other hand, slowed the church in adapting itself to a changing world. Like us all, popes have their strengths and weaknesses. Even saints have their strengths and weaknesses.

The pope’s reflection on the psalms, found in our liturgy today, reveals his love for the psalms, which are such an important part of our liturgy.

The psalms teach us how to pray. They provide a way to praise God and the words to bless God. 

“The psalms have also a wonderful power to awaken in our hearts the desire for every virtue. Athanasius says: Though all Scripture, both old and new, is divinely inspired and has its use in teaching, the Book of Psalms, like a garden enclosing the fruits of all the other books, produces its fruits in song… The psalms seem to me to be like a mirror, in which the person using them can see himself and the stirrings of his own heart; he can recite them against the background of his own emotions. 

Augustine says in his Confessions: How I wept when I heard your hymns and canticles. Those voices flowed into my ears, truth filtered into my heart, and from my heart surged waves of devotion. Tears ran down, and I was happy in my tears.

Who could fail to be moved by those many passages in the psalms which set forth so profoundly the infinite majesty of God, his omnipotence, his justice and goodness and clemency, too deep for words, and all the other infinite qualities of his that deserve our praise?

Who could fail to be roused to the same emotions by the prayers of thanksgiving to God for blessings received, by the petitions, so humble and confident, for blessings still awaited, by the cries of a soul in sorrow for sin committed? 

Who would not be fired with love as he looks on the likeness of Christ, the redeemer, here so lovingly foretold? His was the voice Augustine heard in every psalm, the voice of praise, of suffering, of joyful expectation, of present distress.”

Ezekiel: A Promise for Fallen Shepherds

Ezekiel: Resurrection of Dry Bones

                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                        Artificial Intelligence, Ai, is here. It’s taking what archeologists and historians have found and  reconstructing places like Babylon, Nineveh, Jerusalem and Rome; we can see what daily life was like in those cities, what the streets were like, the buildings, what the people looked like, how the society functioned in the time of Jesus and the prophets. It gives us a fresh look at history.

I’ve been learning more about the world Ezekiel lived in from Ai reconstructions.. 

Many scholars think Ezekiel was a priest from Jerusalem taken with other priests and Jewish leaders as slaves to Babylon. Most of his writings are addressed to Jews enslaved there.

Babylon’s rulers then were building the biggest and most impressive city in the world, and so after capturing Jerusalem they brought a large number of Jerusalem’s leading class to Babylon as slaves. Why Jerusalem’s leading class ? Because they had already built a luxurious city in Jerusalem.They built fine houses;  they knew where to go to for the finest goods and foods. They were builders and developers of a city.

They did it, however, as earlier prophets like Nahum and Haggai tell us, by exploiting the poor. Now they themselves were slaves. The Babylonians brought many conquered peoples to the city for the back-breaking work of digging canals and carrying bricks, but they brought the Jewish leading class for  another role: they were experienced builders. 

In Wednesday’s reading this week Ezekiel speaks to the Jewish exiles, not to praise them for their building skills, but to remind them they were Israel’s failed shepherds:

 “Thus says the Lord GOD: Woe to the shepherds

of Israel who have been pasturing themselves!…You did not strengthen the weak nor heal the sick nor bind up the injured. You did not bring back the strayed nor seek the lost, but you lorded it over them harshly and brutally.”

Let’s not see Ezekiel’s critique  limited to Jewish leaders:  he’s criticizing all rulers, all leaders, all shepherds who make themselves gods, especially at the expense of the poor. He’s careful in his criticism. He avoids the  rulers of Babylon. Instead he criticizes the king of Tyre, who stands for them all. Anyone claiming absolute power over another makes himself a god.

The Babylonians tried taking away the identity of their slaves by forbidding them from keeping their idols and worshipping their gods. Only Marduk, the Babylonian god. was to be worshipped. They tried to make the Jews Babylonians. 

In our final readings this week Ezekiel leaves his critique of the shepherds for a promise of the future for his own people in exile.  God offers mercy and a vision of a renewed kingdom 

“ For I will take you away from among the nations, gather you from all the foreign lands, and bring you back to your own land. I will sprinkle clean water upon you to cleanse you from all your impurities, and from all your idols I will cleanse you.I will give you a new heart and place a new spirit within you, taking from your bodies your stony hearts and giving you natural hearts.” Thursday)

Dry bones, littered on the ground, will rise. “Prophesy and say to them: Thus says the Lord GOD: O my people, I will open your graves and have you rise from them, and bring you back to the land of Israel. Then you shall know that I am the LORD, when I open your graves and have you rise from them.” (Friday) 

Floods of living water will flow over Jerusalem. “And I saw that the temple was filled with the glory of the LORD. Then I heard someone speaking to me from the temple, while the man stood beside me. The voice said to me: 
Son of man, this is where my throne shall be,
this is where I will set the soles of my feet;
here I will dwell among the children of Israel forever.” (Saturday)

St. Bernard August 20

St. Bernard, Perugina, 18th century

August 20th we remember St. Bernard, a spiritual teacher who never goes out of date and a major figure in the renewal of the church in the 12th century.

The image of Jesus communing with Bernard from a painting from 16th century Florence captures the spirituality of the saint. Bernard was attracted to the humanity of Christ, especially his love shown on Calvary. In this scene, Jesus bends down to Bernard to embrace him. The nails cannot hold him from loving the one kneeling before him. Christ’s love is stronger than the images of death, pictured beneath the cross. That has to be the City of Florence in the background. Christ’s love in never confined to one person or age or place.

Bernard lived in “an age of love”, which saw Jesus reaching out to humanity, not primarily humanity crippled by sin, but humanity as his beloved. It’s not surprising that Bernard’s sermons on “The Song of Songs” is considered his greatest work. “The Bridegroom’s love, or rather the love which is the Bridegroom, asks nothing in return but faithful love. Let the beloved, then, love in return. Should not a bride love, and above all, Love’s bride? Could it be that Love not be loved?… It is true that the creature loves less because she is less. But if she loves with her whole being, nothing is lacking where everything is given.”

Bernard was a leader in the 11th century Cistercian reform of Benedictine monasticism which emphasized simplicity of life and devotion to the humanity of Christ. He became a monk at the monastery of Clairvaux in 1112, and then its abbot. By the time of his death in 1153 the order numbered 339 monasteries throughout Europe.

Growth of the Cistercians was due to their support of church reform initiated by Pope Gregory VII, who enlisted monastic orders in his crucial efforts for reforming the papacy. Bernard played an important part in the Gregorian reform as advisor to popes, bishops and secular leaders.

He was a tireless writer whose letters and sermons inspired Christians throughout Europe. He was a healer whose presence drew crowds of people seeking healing. He was a powerful voice promoting the Crusades to rescue the Holy Land..

Here is how he advises we approach God::

“The first involves humbling ourselves before God: “Heal me, Lord, and I shall be healed; save me and I shall be saved. And again, Lord, have mercy on me; heal my soul because I have sinned against you.

Then, leaving sorrow and ourselves behind, it’s time to “abide rather in the Spirit of God with great delight. No longer do we consider what is the will of God for us, but rather what it is in itself.

Under the guidance of the Spirit who gazes into the deep things of God, let us reflect how gracious the Lord is and how good he is in himself. Let us join the Prophet in praying that we may see the Lord’s will and frequent not our own hearts but the Lord’s temple; and let us also say, My soul is humbled within me, therefore I shall be mindful of you.

These two stages sum up the whole of the spiritual life: when we contemplate ourselves we are troubled, but our sadness saves us and brings us to contemplate God. That contemplation in turn gives us the consolation of the joy of the Holy Spirit.

Contemplating ourselves brings fear and humility; contemplating God brings us hope and love.”

“Jesus, what made you so small? Love.”

Lord God,  you made Saint Bernard burn with zeal for your house,  and gave him grace to enkindle and enlighten others in your Church.Grant that by his prayer  we may be filled with the same spirit  and always live as children of the light.Through our Lord Jesus Christ, your Son,  who lives and reigns with you in the unity of the Holy Spirit,  one God, for ever and ever.Amen.

Some audio readings of St Bernard’s works: https://www.gutenberg.org/ebooks/21152

Jesus, what made you so small? Love